Shocking Revelations: An Outlandish Theory on Disease
For many years the cause of cholera was unknown. Theories accounting for the disease ranged from pollution by foul air to one’s elevation above sea level. Even hair color was suggested as a possible culprit…But perhaps one of the most bizarre notions was set fort in a book published in Dublin in 1849. The work of Sir James Murray, a physician, it bore the extraordinary title Electricity as a Cause of Cholera, or Other Epidemics.
Shocking Revelations: An Outlandish Theory on Disease
By Mr Ghaz, January 30, 2010

Shocking Revelations: An Outlandish Theory on Disease

For many years the cause of cholera was unknown. Theories accounting for the disease ranged from pollution by foul air to one’s elevation above sea level. Even hair color was suggested as a possible culprit.

But perhaps one of the most bizarre notions was set fort in a book published in Dublin in 1849. The work of Sir James Murray, a physician, it bore the extraordinary title Electricity as a Cause of Cholera, or Other Epidemics.

Based on a series of articles he had written the previous year for the British medical journal The Lancet, Murray’s book expounded his remarkable theory in great detail. Essentially, he argued that there was no such thing as a germ (he dismissed the idea as “absurd”). All contagious and infectious diseases were caused by one factor: electrical disturbances, with the degree of the disturbance determining the nature of the illness.

Expanding on his theme, Murray explained that diseases such as malaria were caused by disturbed electro- galvanic currents … causing a want of electrical equilibrium in human bodies.” Taking the arbitrary figure of 10,000 as a “natural” level of electricity, he showed, with the help of a detailed chart, that a disruption of+ 01 would result in acute rheumatism, + 70 epilepsy, + 100 “Mania,” +120 tetanus, and +130 “fatal lightning.” On the negative side, -10 would cause influenza, – 90bubonic plague, and -130 ‘fatal thunder.”

Murray also explained that clouds of positive charges were inclined to hover over people, attracting their negative charges. These two “elementary fluids” would then “rush towards each other into the centre of the body” – often with lethal results.
Potent Remedy

The Irish cholera epidemic of 1832, Murray maintained, was caused by “the disturbed galvanic state of earth and air,” and he came up with a number of suggestions to “lighten the density and pressure of the atmosphere around cholera patients.” For example, he had found trough experiments that a potion made from liquid camphor mixed with “fluid magnesia” was effective against the electrically induced cholera.

Murray also advocated wearing silk (or, in the case of the poor, flannel) next to the skin. Sleeping under silk sheets, he claimed, would assist “in warding off the mysterious and all- pervading currents of irregular electricity.” Damp floors, he thought, should be covered with quicklime to dry them out, and baskets of lime placed all around the patient’s house “to abate untoward galvanism.”
Murray had proposed further defenses: houses should be built on insulated platforms, beds balanced on glass bottles, and huge batteries positioned around cities to absorb charges. Quarantine, he insisted, was a waste of time.

Murray was not without his supporter in this vies of the association between electricity and disease. And he was neither hardly the first nor the last to promulgate such ideas. Some 50years earlier a U.S. quack named Elisha Perkins had marketed two expensive rods that he called “tractors.” Each was made of three metals: one of iron, silver, and platinum, the other of copper, zinc, and gold. When the rods were drawn over the body, claimed Perkins, the electricity they generated discharged all known diseases.
Similarly, late in the 19th century, the London Medical Battery Company sold electric corsets, claiming that they would cure everything from gout to consumption.

However out blandish these ideas may seem, in some ways we not entirely free of such notions today. Many people still believe that car sickness can be cured by grounding automobiles with metal contact strips that drag along the road and drain away static electricity.
Liked it

Katien | Jan 31, 2010 | Reply
It is amazing how people can get carried away with proving their theory to be correct!
Frances Lawrence | Jan 31, 2010 | Reply
It sounds odd to us now but if people had not worked on different theories we would not have found the true cause.
albert1jemi | Jan 31, 2010 | Reply
excellent information
willie wondka | Jan 31, 2010 | Reply
what more can i say, excellent read from you as always.
Susan | Jan 31, 2010 | Reply
Were there any results in the information you found? Obviously there was something that occurred in order for these people to create these theories and sell them.
It might be that we see these theories as outlandish, but couldn’t it be that we are ignoring a branch of physical phenomena that would prove useful if further studied?
I’m just proposing this. But our current medical “professionals” believe in chemical imbalances in the brain as the cause of depression and insanity (without any medical proof or test that shows such a thing exists). They treat cancer with poisons that often kill the patient faster than the cancer would.
Phill Senters | Jan 31, 2010 | Reply
Crazy Ideas… Some people will try anything to make money. It’s amazing that anyone believed some of these things.
Sherry | Jan 31, 2010 | Reply
Interesting article, mrghaz.
Mukundan | Feb 1, 2010 | Reply
That was a nice article. Liked ur post very much. I have written an article on Menopause . When you get time please visit and comment. We shall maintain a good commenting – relationship.
revivor | Feb 5, 2010 | Reply
there are many who feel that xrays, mobiles, wifi and other “invisibles” have an unknown impact on our internal organs – especially with regard to cancer etc – makes this an interesting story
T. S. GARP | Feb 7, 2010 | Reply
Almost anything out of balance with nature and can be the cause of so many things not entirely healthy for us. Good post!