Organic: Getting Hype Back to Eye Level

Let’s start out with a definition of organic farming I found in the net. It read: an ecological production management system that promotes and enhances biodiversity, biological cycles and soil biological activity. It is based on minimal use of off-farm inputs and on management practices that restore, maintain and enhance ecological harmony. (The Organic Foods Production Act) Sounds pretty brainy.

Let’s take these uppity words down to English common sense language. To do this, let’s step back to the 17^th century. At that time the CEO of an ecological production management system was called a farmer, his ecological production activity farming, and his management system common sense. Biodiversity meant planting, growing, and raising everything on his own to feed family and retainers, then sell off surplus products. Biological cycles were yearly crop rotations. And soil biological activity was called letting a field lie fallow for a season. All in all, our scientific organic producer would have been called a good farmer. Today, common sense needs legislation and a supervising body; that is new.

You might want to ask me why I stepped back to the 17^th century. I chose that time as being before the great errors were committed, industrialisation and the advent of my special friends, the chemical and pharmaceutical industries. The positive aspect I find in the situation is that humankind really is able to learn from its own faults, even if it takes more than 200 years.

Does this mean the good farmer of today produces the same high quality as our CEO in 1650? No. But it’s not really the farmer’s fault, or mostly not. If his fields abut the M25 or Route 66, he may preach organic with angel’s voice, he will still be bringing in polluted crops. The organic fields on this side of the motorway get as much pollution from the motorway as the non-organic fields on the other side. Conclusion: Don’t believe just everything they tell you about organic crops. With this, I don’t want to say that the organic food will be no better, because it gets the same pollution from outside sources, but it’s not heaven sent either.

Secondary problems not under the present farmers control are pesticides, insecticides, mycocides, and hormones used by his predecessor. These artificial products, rightly shunned by the good farmer, are not biodegradable. They stay in the soil, in the trees, and in the bushes for ages and continue polluting his crop maybe for generations. Again, his products certainly are better than if he continued using toxic waste, but a far cry from perfect. Short of taking out all plants and digging out the soil five meters down, there is nothing to be done about that.

This could lead you to the conclusion that growing your own organic food might be best. For several reasons you are right: Doing it yourself, you know what you did and that it is up to the standards you expect of organic foods. It also means that you live more healthily with all the exercise you get. As you get your food directly from the garden without lying around in warehouses for weeks, it will contain more vitamins and essential trace elements. Having it grown yourself it will also taste better.

Now before you rush out to start your own organic garden, you should do your homework. I am not talking about books on gardening, though that certainly will be helpful, too. I am talking of the history of your garden. You should spend some time to find out what was there, either directly or in the neighbourhood, before you moved in. If your next door neighbour was Duracell producing batteries in the fifties, chances are that your organic growth might come up mighty toxic. The same holds true if your land was used by a mining company in the 18^th century. Subject one therefore is local history, gardening comes later.

If all my buts haven’t put you off organic food by now and you are not a gardener, there are some articles on buying organic foods available you might want to consult:

Switching to Organic Foods with tips on how to read labels correctly.

Should You Shop at an Organic Food Market? with tips about pitfalls outside of organic considerations.

How to Buy Organic Without Spending More Money to keep your organic wishes in reach of your budget.

Those who read my article Healthy Living by Tomato and Friends know I couldn’t leave the following article unmentioned: Conventional Vs. Organic Ketchup: Which Should You Buy?