rss
6

The Danger of Psycho-therapy

If you’ve been and don’t feel better…

Many times when lesbians attend therapists, (this probably holds true for Gays as well)
they have to spend the first session going through the usual; ‘no, I wasn’t abused by my
mother, sister, uncle, father, cousin, milkman..’
, which usually gets the ‘why are you so
defensive?’
response.

Newbies, however, might be confused into remembering events that never happened, or
never happened that way, because even gay/lesbian therapists usually start with
the premises that you got ‘here’ because of…..

Take Shirley.

She had a really weird past.

When she was about nine months old she went to live with her Aunt who had
just lost her two year old daughter Ellen. 

Her parents were in a bad place, so thought to ’spare’ Shirley, and as Auntie May
was so avid and had everything already, so went Shirley.

Auntie May began to call Shirley ‘Ellen‘, and treat her as the replacement.
When Shirley was about three years old, Auntie May  became pregnant. 
She decided to return Shirley to sender.

Shirley’s folks actually would have preferred another few months to really get
themselves together, but took their daughter with the best intentions.

So here’s Shirley; she doesn’t know who her parents are, what her name
is, where she belongs, and there’s no one there to explain it.
Not then.
Not when she was older.
Not even when she was a woman grown.

Shirley happened to be a lesbian. She was always a lesbian. She was never
not a lesbian. 

Due to her feelings of insecurity, Shirley attended a psycho-therapist, who focused on…
yah…her being a lesbian.

(I should of warned you to get the barf bag, sisters.)

There had to be a ‘reason’ why Shirley was a lesbian, and clearly
her feelings of confusion were due to some ‘abuse’.

For a couple of years, Shirley was more messed up than anyone else.
She had this unremembered ‘memory’ of all forms of abuse, and felt
like crap.

Funnily enough, Auntie May, drunk at some social function, blabbed
about what she’d done to Shirley.  Shirley remembered her past in
crystal clarity.

She remembered how she’d felt when she’d been ‘dumped’ in the
strange place with the almost remembered strangers she was to
call ‘mommy’ and ‘daddy’, now.

It all fell into place.

Suddenly Shirley felt as if the sun was shining on her, and it all made
sense.  She was never ‘abused’ in the classical sense.  She was simply
feeling abandoned, neglected, uncertain of her identity.

In a case like this, suing the psycho-therapist was knee jerk.

Many patients, however, are not as fortunate as Shirley. They go through
life carrying the weight of horrible events which being false, and known to
be false in their very core, just makes matters worse.

So be careful, Newbies. 

If you don’t remember being abused, if nothing in your life ‘confirms’ it,
maybe the only abuse you suffered is by therapist.

And that can be treated by lawsuit.

6
Liked it

RSSComments: 6  |  Post a Comment  |  Trackback URL

  1. Interesting topic for sure. I believe some need psycho-therapy. (definitely not be for being gay though) And then their are some who do not benefit at all. It kind of opens doors that were closed within the mind for a reason. Does re-living terrible events in our past really help the individual? Some say yes. I say no. Matter of opinion…..a lot of Dr.’s are getting rich off the suffering of others. A lot of the treatment options recquire medication. Pop a pill and everything will be okay. Right? Totally wrong. Great article. Apologize for the comment rant.

  2. Great comment RS Wing. I was always chary of psycho-therapy
    esp. when you know people who have gone for years and are still shaky. The lawsuits that are being won against therapists today
    could fill a book.

    Reliving terrible events doesn’t help…and reliving terrible events that never happened is even worse. In Shirley’s case the therapist ‘invented’ a trauma.

  3. Great topic. My distrust of psycho babble obviously matches your own.
    Your sentence about Shirley being returned – can also read that Shirley was pregnant at three. IMO.
    Also aren’t lesbians gay? Or do you differentiate between men(gay) and women (lesbians).

  4. I’ll correct the sentence, Oldster. Yes. I can’t speak historically,
    but over the past twenty years, there has been so many lawsuits
    against psychotherapists (kept quiet obviously) many are a variation on the theme of false memory.

    I always differentiate between Gays and Lesbians as very often the ‘Gay’ agenda doesn’t take in Lesbian concerns.

    Just as you’d get a second opinion when a doctor tells you X you should get a second opinion when a therapist tells you X… esp. from a different school of therapists.

  5. You are so right on! I’ve also known this to happen … I’m wondering if a friend of mine? ,,,hummmm….I better pass this on! You know I always love your work!

  6. thanks Jenna. Yes, I’m very wary of a lot of therapists who create maladies. So many times when there is ’sexual ambiguity’ or the person ’suffers’ from ‘homosexuality’ there’s a reason of ‘abuse’.

    Even lesbian therapists, if you can believe it, have this idea that there is ’something’ beneath the surface they can find.

    For every ‘Shirley’, there are dozens of others who never hear the truth.

RSSPost a Comment